Posterous theme by Cory Watilo

Filed under: current events

If I Were a GOP Candidate for President...

There have been several deeply disturbing moments in recent GOP debates among the candidates for their party's nomination.  Each of these incidents happened because of audience reaction -- in one, the audience cheers for the death penalty and execution of people; in another, when one candidate was asked what should happen to the uninsured, shouts of "let them die" rang out; and in the third, a gay soldier who was asking a question was booed.

The most shocking aspect of all three of these incidents is that not one candidate stepped up and spoke up to say that these reactions were wrong.  There was silence from the candidates... and tacit support, it would seem.

Now despite my serious policy differences with the current GOP candidates, I don't believe that all of them revel in state-sponsored executions, honestly believe that the answer to our health care predicament is to "let them die" or that any soldier should be booed for serving our country.

But all of them were silent. And as Martin Luther King, Jr has famously noted in his day (and I believe it still applies in our day), "History will have to record that the greatest tragedy of this period of social transition was not the strident clamor of the bad people, but the appalling silence of the good people."

Silence from the candidates under these circumstances is shameful and unacceptable. I believe it also disqualfies each of them for the presidency.  Standing up and speaking out on principle is essential for our leaders.  By not speaking out, these candidates either signal that they agree with the crowds or lack the backbone and conviction to challenge their own supporters.  Either way, they should be ashamed and have no business running for president.

In case you missed the moments, here are the brief video clips, followed by, if I were one of the candidates advisors, I would have counseled them to say:

DEATH PENALTY


Response should have been:  "Let's all just hold on here a second.  I understand the desire of the public for the death penalty.  Some crimes are so heinous that the death penalty must be used. But let us never cheer or celebrate the use of the death penalty.  Every time the state chooses to execute a criminal, it is a human tragedy. It is a human tragedy for the victims of their crime and their families.  It is a human tragedy for the broader community.  And it is a human tragedy even for the life being executed.  For we believe all life has infinite potential, and it is always tragedy when a life full of potential chooses a road of death, destruction and murder.  Yes, we will use the death penalty as needed -- but never with joy, never with cheers and always with sense of humbleness andseriusness that befits the issue.  To cheer death is to violate our basic principles as a party committed to life -- and we should never do it."

MEDICAL INSURANCE

Response should have been: "These are very complicated issues, as you know. And I do not support Obamacare or individual mandates. But obviously, "let him die" is unacceptable public policy and inconsitent with our values as a party.  Whatever solution we do end up with -- and I believe there are are solutions that will not bankrupt America, will not federalize our entire medical system, will not socialize our medicine -- but whatever solution we do end up with will need to be one that values life, sustains life and improves life for all Americans. That is what it means to be a truly pro-life party... from conception to death.  So no, "let him die" is not acceptable social policy."

DADT

Response should have been: "Hold on a second... I need to interject here. I don't care what your politics are or where are stand on the issue of homosexuals serving openly in our military. No soldier who honorably serves our nation should ever be booed or disrespected the way I just saw happen here.  That is unacceptable.  As a nation, we are capable of having a civilized policy debate whithout dishonoring the men and women who serve in our military.  We are a party that supports and honors our troops -- and as President I will make sure that all of our troops are supported and honored."

Now please note, these are the answers I would have suggested a GOP candidate give.  These are not my own answers.  For the record, I oppose the death penalty 100% of the time, I support Obamacare and individual mandates, and I support the repeal of DADT.

But even if you are a conservative on these issues, there is a way to do so that is honorable and has integrity... and then there is a way that is shameful and embarrassing.  So far, we have only seen the shameful and embarrassing approach from the declared candidates... highlighted by their silence in response to these three incidents. 

Please Lord, Protect Us From Your Followers...

[WARNING... angry rant to follow...]

I am an EVANGELICAL CHRISTIAN.  I don't deny it.  In fact, I have been an out-of-the-closet evangelical for 19 years.

I am not a FUNDAMENTALIST CHRISTIAN in any sense of the word. 

It is worth noting that almost all FUNDAMENTALIST CHRISTIANS would probably be considered EVANGELICALS, but ALL EVANGELICALS ARE NOT FUNDAMENTALISTS.

That said, you should know that I am deeply embarrassed by some of the bullshit crap that passes as teaching/theology/leadership out there these days.  In fact, I am not only embarrassed, I am angry.  I am angry because these kinds of people actually KEEP PEOPLE FROM JESUS.  Trust me, it is true.  Not only to they PREACH NONSENSE, but they MUDDY THE GOSPEL with their nonsense.

Most of the time I let this stuff just go.  I don't make a big deal out of it and don't publicly criticize it.  But sometimes I am pushed over the edge.  The rejection of these people and the false gospel they preach is not the result of an anti-Christian bias among the mainstream media as much as the fact that these people SOUND INSANE.

Let's be clear... claiming that OPRAH WINFREY IS THE ANTI-CHRIST and TALKING ABOUT SEX WITH DEMONS... this is as crazy as claiming that the end of the world was to come this past May.

I don't doubt these people love Jesus and are saved and will be at the heavenly banquet... I just wish they would shut up in the mean time.

If you don't know what I am talking about, watch this video:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

[End of Rant...]

Why Jim Wallis is Wrong

Tony Jones has written a great blog post about Jim Wallis, Sojourners and their recent decision to not allow a Gay Christian group to purchase an advertisement in the magazine. Here is that post in full:

So, it seems that Jim Wallis* has gotten into a bit of a kerfuffle for rejecting a magazine ad from Believe Out Loud, a pan-denominational campaign to increase the number of congregations that are welcoming** to LGBT folks.  The best rundown of the controversy with all the important links can be found at Religion Dispatches.

As RD posted and others have made clear, Wallis has avoided addressing LGBT issues for years.  And that’s because Wallis knows, as he states in his apologia, that LGBT issues in the church constitute a “wedge issue.”

But more to the point, affirmation of gays in any way in the church in America these days is a shibboleth, as I have written previously.  That is, if you affirm that homosexual persons who are in any way sexually active can have a role of leadership in the church or should be afforded to right to marry and awarded all of the privileges accorded thereto, then you are, de facto, kicked out of evangelicalism.  Suddenly, 60% of the Christian market in America is, for all intents and purposes, closed to you.  No more fundraising therein, and no more book sales thereto.

Jim Wallis knows this.  Jay Bakker and I and other straight allies of GLBT persons know this first-hand.  Rich Cizik knows this.  And any number of other Christian leaders on the scene today have watched the examples of those of us who publicly ally ourselves with GLBT issues in the church, and it has scared them off from publicly stating what they privately believe, which is that gays should be included in the church.

To those who pastor churches, I understand your hesitation to speak publicly in affirmation of gay ordination and gay marriage.  You have congregations to pastor, and you may feel that your commitment to the unity of the flock trumps your personal convictions on a particular and controversial matter.  But to Jim Wallis, I have this to say:

If you publicly affirm GLBT persons and their full inclusion in the life of the church and in the marriage laws of our country, you will be amazed at the support that you will receive.

I’ve been asked many times if I regret making the decision to publicly support GLBT persons and issues, and I can unequivocally say that, no, I have no regrets.  I’ve heard Jay Bakker say the same thing.  It may have cost us support, speaking gigs, and book contracts, but it’s been totally worth it.

Nota bene, I am not a martyr. I made a public stand on this issue as I have with many others.  I have no congregation to shepherd.  Therefore, I have more freedom to take controversial stands with minimal consequences.  I think that Jim Wallis is in the same boat (though I recognize that he shepherds a large, donation-based non-profit.)

But here’s the thing.  I get questions like this a lot: “C’mon, you know him, what does Jim Wallis/Rob Bell/Shane Claiborne/fill-in-the-blank really think about gays?”  The point is, a lot of people are making a lot of assumptions about leaders in the Protestant church who are progressive on other issues.  And the questions those people ask me, I think, disguise a more fundamental question: Can someone who is theologically thoughtful and progressive on other biblical and social issues remain conservative on issues of human sexuality?

Jim Wallis, Shane Claiborne, and others have, to this point, answered yes to that question.  I have my doubts about whether that position is tenable in the long run.

But here’s my final point, and the one that Jim Wallis may be missing: regardless of his stance on GLBT issues, I think that evangelicals have already kicked him out. They have Brian McLaren, Rob Bell, Doug Pagitt, and me.  I think they have him as well.  So, if (when) Sojourners does publicly affirm gays, I don’t think they’ll see any change…except maybe an infusion of donations.


*Sojourners = Jim Wallis

**Welcoming ≠ open, affirming, gay marriage, or gay ordination.  Welcoming = welcoming, and nothing more.

THOUGHTS?

My Prayer for the Mayor's Prayer Breakfast for the National Day of Prayer

Today is the National Day of Prayer, and for the second time, MACC Charities hosted the Manchester Mayor's Prayer Breakfast.  It was a great time of fellowship and prayer this morning, with lots of diversity.  In addition to a broad spectrum of Christian churches represented, both the Jewish community and Islamic community were part of the prayer this year.

For my prayer, I adapted a prayer from Shane Claiborne.  Here it is:

God of Avraham, Yitzak & Yacov,
God of Miriam, Hannah, Rizpah, and David…
God of Elijah, Amos, Ruth, Isaiah, Deborah…
God of Mary, John the Baptizer, Peter, Paul, Philemon and Onesimus…
God of Anthony, Ambrose, Teresa of Avila, and Francis of Assisi,
God of Dorothy Day, Martin Luther King, Mother Teresa,
        William Wilberforce, and Oscar Romero
God of Manchester, America and the world... God of us all...
and God of love, grace, and hope…

Thank you...
Thank you for creating a perfect world.
Forgive us for the mess we have made of it.
Thank you for creating Jubilee, gleaning, and Sabbath as patterns to
ensure that the poor are cared for, the earth rests, and inequality is dismantled.

Forgive us...

for choosing the patterns of empire.
Thank you for using the weak things to shame the strong and the
foolish things to confound the wise.
Protect us from becoming too strong or too wise.
Protect us from ourselves.

Forgive us…
for the groaning of creation
for the millions who die of hunger and curable diseases
for warehousing people in prisons and using them for labor
for the scandal of billions wasted in war
for worrying about tomorrow and storing up more than this day our daily bread
for an economy that mirrors the seven deadly sins
for our Caesars and our Herods
for the violence and greed in our own hearts
Save us from ourselves.

Deliver us…
from the arrogance of power
from the myth of redemptive violence
from the tyranny of greed
from the ugliness of racism
from false hope and counterfeit change
from the cancer of hatred
from the seduction of wealth
from the idolatry of nationalism
from the paralysis of cynicism
from the ghettoes of poverty
from the ghettoes of wealth
from the blood-stained pages of history
and from the legacy of slavery.
Deliver us oh God.

Give us the courage…
to bless the poor in a world that blesses the middle class.
to bless the meek in a world that admires aggression.
to bless the hungry in a world that feeds the already fed.
to bless the merciful in a world that shows no mercy on evildoers.
to bless the pure in heart in a world of clutter and noise.
to bless the peacemakers in a world that baptizes bombs.

Give us imagination…
that we might not conform to the patterns of this world.
that we might shatter indifference and interrupt injustice with grace
that we might choose the cross over the sword
that we might be as shrewd as serpents and as innocent as doves
that we might choose the dream of God over the dreams of nations
that we might cling to the God that so loved the world, not just America
that we might allow our Jesus to change America rather than America to change our Jesus.

Give us your eyes...

to see the world as you see it.
Give us your hands...
to engage to the world as would have us engage it.
Give us your feet...
that we might go where you would have us go.
 

And may we especially have eyes to see --
and hearts to love --
the lost, the least and the lonely
in our midst and in our community.
 
In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.   

Amen.

 

Bin Laden & Bad Hermeneutics

In the immediate aftermath of the historic announcement that Osama Bin Laden had been killed by U.S. Military personel, Facebook and Twitter erupted with reactions -- including from many pastors and Christian leaders.

For example, some posted this from Proverbs: 

‎"When justice is done, it brings joy to the righteous but terror to evildoers" - Proverbs 21:15

And others posted this:

"Rejoice not when thine enemy falleth and let not thine heart be glad when he is overthrown." -- Proverbs 24:17

Seems like a contradiction, doesn't it?  Or at least you could say "see... you can make the Bible say anything you it to!" -- true, but only if you use flawed hermeneutics. (I have written a lot more about hermeneutics and good interpretation of the Bible here.)

Here is we an important and basic hermeneutical principal at work: the difference between DESCRIPTIVE WISDOM and PRESCRIPTIVE WISDOM.

Proverbs 21:15 is an example of DESCRIPTIVE WISDOM. That is, it describes what happens in a given situation.  It says, in this case, that when justice is done, certain things happen.  There is not a judgement made whether these things are good or bad; it is merely a descripotion of what is. And one of the things about WISDOM is that it accurately describes reality.

On the other hand, Proverbs 24:17 is PRESCRIPTIVE WISDOM -- it tells us what wise people SHOULD DO.  The grammar in the sentence tells us this.  It is in the indicative case.  "Rejoice not..." -- almost a command.  It is PRESCRIPTIVE.

So in this case, bother verses are saying different things and both are true.

But here is the important point: when it comes to building a Biblical worldview and a Biblical ethical paradigm, it we remember which is descriptive and which is prescriptive.  As Christians -- and even more, simply as wise people -- we should follow the advice of Proverbs 24:7, not fall into the pattern described in Proverbs 21:15.

As you can see, good heremeneutics really does matter.

How Should We Feel About the Death of Osama Bin Laden?

Last night's announcement by President Obama that Osama Bin Laden is dead was historical and remarkable.  Following the story online and through social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter, one of the questions that is worth pondering is, as Christians, how should we feel about his death?

On the one hand, there is justice in his death.

But on the other, we are counseled in Proverbs 24:17, "Rejoice not when thine enemy falleth & let not thine heart be glad when he is overthrown."

This wise counsel should cause us to be humble.

And of course, Jesus teaches us to LOVE OUR ENEMIES -- and pray for them.

I -- like virtually all Americans -- remember exactly where I was on 9-11.  And those memories are still painful.  As Obama said last night, for all of us, the tragedy of that day is seared on our collective memories.

I am not really sure what the answer to the question of how we should feel is, but perhaps a hint is found in how Jews throughout the world celebrate the Passover.  During the seder, when we come to the part about the Ten Plagues, we take some of our wine and drip it on the seder plate.  The symbolism is that, even though we celebrate our own freedom, our joy (and therefor our wine) is diminished by the reality of the suffering that our enemies have undergone.  The rabbis teach that we cannot experience full joy in the midst of any death and destruction.

So while it is certainly appropriate to celenbrate justice and freedom -- and to give credit to our military and intelligence personel for a job well done -- we must also temper our joy because we, as followers of the Way, never rejoice in death and destruction.

We should also pause and reflect upon the cost of this 10-year war in Afghanistan -- in terms of American and NATO troop losses as well as the countless civilian deaths that have taken place.  All in all, both a good day for the cause of justice, but also a sobering day that reminds us of the brokenness of our world and should lead all of us to pray: COME LORD JESUS! MARANATHA!

Royal Wedding: Bishop of London's Sermon

“Be who God meant you to be and you will set the world on fire.” So said St Catherine of Siena whose festival day it is today. Marriage is intended to be a way in which man and woman help each other to become what God meant each one to be, their deepest and truest selves.

Many are full of fear for the future of the prospects of our world but the message of the celebrations in this country and far beyond its shores is the right one – this is a joyful day! It is good that people in every continent are able to share in these celebrations because this is, as every wedding day should be, a day of hope.  

In a sense every wedding is a royal wedding with the bride and the groom as king and queen of creation, making a new life together so that life can flow through them into the future.

William and Catherine, you have chosen to be married in the sight of a generous God who so loved the world that he gave himself to us in the person of Jesus Christ.

And in the Spirit of this generous God, husband and wife are to give themselves to each another.

A spiritual life grows as love finds its centre beyond ourselves. Faithful and committed relationships offer a door into the mystery of spiritual life in which we discover this; the more we give of self, the richer we become in soul; the more we go beyond ourselves in love, the more we become our true selves and our spiritual beauty is more fully revealed. In marriage we are seeking to bring one another into fuller life.

It is of course very hard to wean ourselves away from self-centredness. And people can dream of doing such a thing but the hope should be fulfilled it is necessary a solemn decision that, whatever the difficulties, we are committed to the way of generous love.

You have both made your decision today – “I will” – and by making this new relationship, you have aligned yourselves with what we believe is the way in which life is spiritually evolving, and which will lead to a creative future for the human race.

We stand looking forward to a century which is full of promise and full of peril. Human beings are confronting the question of how to use wisely a power that has been given to us through the discoveries of the last century. We shall not be converted to the promise of the future by more knowledge, but rather by an increase of loving wisdom and reverence, for life, for the earth and for one another.

Marriage should transform, as husband and wife make one another their work of art. It is possible to transform as long as we do not harbour ambitions to reform our partner. There must be no coercion if the Spirit is to flow; each must give the other space and freedom. Chaucer, the London poet, sums it up in a pithy phrase:

“Whan maistrie [mastery] comth, the God of Love anon,

Beteth his wynges, and farewell, he is gon.”

As the reality of God has faded from so many lives in the West, there has been a corresponding inflation of expectations that personal relations alone will supply meaning and happiness in life. This is to load our partner with too great a burden. We are all incomplete: we all need the love which is secure, rather than oppressive, we need mutual forgiveness, to thrive.

As we move towards our partner in love, following the example of Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit is quickened within us and can increasingly fill our lives with light. This leads to a family life which offers the best conditions in which the next generation can practise and exchange those gifts which can overcome fear and division and incubate the coming world of the Spirit, whose fruits are love and joy and peace.

I pray that all of us present and the many millions watching this ceremony and sharing in your joy today, will do everything in our power to support and uphold you in your new life. And I pray that God will bless you in the way of life that you have chosen, that way which is expressed in the prayer that you have composed together in preparation for this day:

God our Father, we thank you for our families; for the love that we share and for the joy of our marriage.

In the busyness of each day keep our eyes fixed on what is real and important in life and help us to be generous with our time and love and energy.

Strengthened by our union help us to serve and comfort those who suffer. We ask this in the Spirit of Jesus Christ. Amen.    

-- Dr. Richard Chartres, Anglican Bishop of London